WASHINGTON - The Nuclear Regulatory Commission said
Nov. 17 that Calvert Cliffs nuclear power plant is secure and regulators found no safety
concerns that would keep the plant from getting its license renewed.Baltimore Gas &
Electric, which owns Calvert Cliffs, can adequately manage effects of aging at the Lusby
plant, the NRC concluded in the safety evaluation report.
"There is reasonable assurance that actions have been or will be taken to manage
effects of aging for a 20-year period of extended operation, such that the plant can
continue to operate safe[ly]," said the Nov. 17 report.
The report was released less than a week after a federal appeals court ordered the NRC
to provide the public "a meaningful hearing" on the relicensing of Calvert
Cliffs before the process is completed.
An official with the National Whistleblower Center, which brought the suit against the
NRC, said earlier this week that the court ruling would likely delay a final decision on
Calvert Cliffs by two to three years. Proceeding without that hearing, the official said,
would be illegal.
But NRC staffers said they expect to stick to an earlier timetable that calls for a
final decision on the renewal of the Calvert Cliffs license by May. The NRC is still
considering what action, if any, it will take in response to the court ruling, a spokesman
said Nov. 17.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled Nov. 12 that the NRC acted
unfairly when it ignored a request from the National Whistleblower Center for a hearing on
Calvert Cliffs.
"The public has been closed out of the process," said Paul Gunter, director
of the Reactor Watchdog Project for the Nuclear Information and Resources Service.
"The NRC has provided the utility with a shield from public scrutiny."
But a spokesman for BG&E said the review process "has been extremely
thorough" and should be allowed to proceed.
"(The safety report) offers a compelling argument for the continuous operation of
Calvert Cliffs," said BG&E spokesman Karl Neddenien.
If relicensing is granted, Calvert Cliffs' two reactors will operate until 2034 and
2036, another 20 years beyond their original 40-year operating licenses.
Calvert Cliffs produces nearly half of BG&E's electricity and generates power for 1
million people in central Maryland
In October, the NRC concluded that relicensing Calvert Cliffs would not pose a threat
to the environment, the other major hurdle in the relicensing review.
Public interest groups have charged that the process has been too fast and not all
safety concerns were addressed. Calvert Cliffs is the first plant in the nation to seek a
renewal of its operating license under new streamlined NRC regulations and its progress is
being watched closely by both sides of the nuclear power debate.
"The whole term 'nuclear safety' is an oxymoron," said Gunter. "It's a
inherently dangerous process and an inherently dangerous industry that has been
aging."